Wine Enthusiast Catalog WineExpress.com Wine Shop Wine Enthusiast Magazine
Visit our other sites:
NEW

Wine Enthusiast Catalog
Gift Ideas Ships Free  Wine Cellar Outlet
Retail Showroom   Request A Catalog   Track Order   Customer Care   My Account
Expert Advice - 800.356.8466
Early Bird Prices Available Now for The Wine & Food Event of The Year! Buy Tickets

Search Go
View CartView Cart

Glassware Decanters & Aerators Corkscrews Serve & Preserve Housewares Wine Furniture
Refrigerated Wine Cabinets Wine Racks Cooling Units Wine Cellar Design Apparel Collecting Gift Baskets

CELLAR MADNESS - Wine Cellars SHIP FREE - March Only!
 Home » Reviews
 
 

Page 1 2 of 2 | Next


By TMPD

from Santa Barbara, CA

About Me Connoisseur

Verified

Get ready for frustration

 
2.0

Pros

  • Attractive Design
  • Quiet

Cons

  • Set up

Best Uses

Once put together it is nice to have. However, the process is very frustrating and the instructions are way too basic and short to be helpful. The first doors I was sent were bowed and the replacement doesn't hold suction.


By Standlow

from Missouri

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

Straightforward and just as advertised

 
4.0

Pros

  • Attractive Design
  • Quiet

Cons

Best Uses

  • Wine cellar
  • Bar
  • Kitchen

The unit was easy to assemble. We are pleased with its quiet operation. It's a great feeling not having to worry anymore about temperature variances in the wine cellar.


By Fireman Bill

from San Antonio, TX

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

Outstanding bargain

 
5.0

Pros

  • Precise Temperature
  • Attractive Design

Cons

Best Uses

I replaced a defunct SubZero freezer that had been converted for wine; trust me, this is way better. I won't say that it is perfect for everyone, but in its location at our place, for our needs, it's an outstanding bargain. Lots of space, a compressor that even my wife feels is not loud enough to note, and close tolerances on temperatures. I did have to by a proper tube of caulking to finish that job, and the instructions for assembly are virtually useless. It helps if you have assembled childrens' toys. Also, I would not suggest that the unit be placed in a dining room or other space where one might prefer a noiseless background. Having said that, this unit looks good, the doors seal with authority, the glass front is a surprising luxury for the price. With the above caveats, I can strongly recommend it.


By GP

from Brandon,Mississippi

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

B.Y.O. is terrific!

 
4.0

Pros

  • Precise Temperature
  • Adjustable Shelving
  • Quiet
  • Attractive Design

Cons

Best Uses

  • Bar

I use this product for wine storage and aging.It works at the temperature I like.GP


By Crusher

from Los Gatos, ca

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

Frustrating start but satisfied finish

 
3.0

Pros

  • Precise Temperature

Cons

  • Loud

Best Uses

  • Bar
  • Commercial Use
  • Restaurant

As mentioned in other reviews, the instructions to put this together are not complete. They need someone who did not write the instructions to put it together and add the steps and part numbers that are needed. (You need 6 hours and some help to put it together.) Once together the unit keeps accurate temperature after the cooler is calibrated. It definitely does not hold 500 bottles more like 350 with a good mixture of varietals. The unit is a little loud for a dinning room but for the price if you don't mind the above issues the unit is worth it and I would recommend it.


By chipper

from Houston, Texas

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

good phrase

 
4.0

Pros

  • Adjustable Shelving
  • Attractive Design
  • Quiet
  • Faily easy to assemble

Cons

  • Lighting is cheesy

Best Uses

  • Bar

I have three other similar wine cellars. This one is comparable,quiet, and adaptable. The lighting in it is poor


By Crusher

from Los Gatos, ca

About Me Casual Taster

Verified

once put together item works well

 
3.0

Pros

  • Precise Temperature
  • Adjustable Shelving

Cons

  • Loud

Best Uses

As mentioned in other reviews, the instructions to put this together are not complete. They need someone who did not write the instructions to put it together and add the steps and part numbers that are needed. (You need 6 hours and some help to put it together.) Once together the unit keeps accurate temperature after the cooler is calibrated. It definitely does not hold 500 bottles more like 350 with a good mixture of varietals. The unit is a little loud for a dinning room but for the price if you don't mind the above issues the unit is worth it and I would recommend it.


By Bald Traveler

from New England

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

(1 of 1 customer found this review helpful)

Good for the money

 
4.0

Pros

  • Adjustable Shelving

Cons

  • Loud

Best Uses

  • Basement

Overall, this is a decent item. Not particularly attractive and a bit loud. It is cool in our basement this time of year so it dies not run at all, but we will see how it fares in the summer. I bet the tiny condensation pan will be full twice a day and require some modification to be workable. WIth 400 bottles it is full, I am not sure how to get more in and still have access to them easily.


By Mikey

from Virginia

About Me Casual Taster

Verified

(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)

Need improvment

 
3.0

Pros

  • Adjustable Shelving
  • Attractive Design

Cons

  • Loud

Best Uses

WHen I read the other reviews thay mentioned that this product was hard to assemble. I would like to mention that this product was by far the most frustrating piece for frenature that I have ever assembled. THe hardware used to hold the side together is of very low quality. I have only had my cabnet assembled for two weeks and I am slowy comming to enjoy it more. But I was somewhat dissapointed on the day I put it together. Also the gaskets on the door have a tendangy to leek.


By Jamie

from Tampa, FL

About Me Connoisseur

Verified

(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)

A good platform that you can enhance

 
4.0

Pros

  • Economical
  • Customizable

Cons

  • Loud

Best Uses

  • Extra Storage
  • Bar

I bought two of these units based on price and they are serving me well. I found the directions a little vague, but I am a handy guy, so I was able to tweak them a bit and assemble both of the units, by myself, with no issues. The trick to doing it by yourself is to start it on it's side, using the weight of the unit in your favor, rather than on it's back. Also, I had plenty of room to roll the unit on to it's sides and back easily. I agree with others who mention the caulk that comes with it not enough. I used extra caulk between the seams and in the cracks for air tight fit. For mine, I added my own LED lights on a switch, and some other things to make it a little better for me.


By The Wine Olympian

from Orlando, FL

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)

Good for the price

 
3.0

Pros

  • Ample Space
  • Adjustable Shelving

Cons

  • Poor Insulation

Best Uses

  • Bar

For the price, this is a decent unit. A comparable commercial unit that holds ~500 bottles is about $4K. You won't really get 500 bottles in this unit, since many bottles don't conform to a standard Bordeaux bottle (ie. Pinot Noir bottles, large-format, etc). My unit currently holds ~250 bottles and could easily hold another 50 bottles before I have to reorganize.I've looked at many, many wine cellars/coolers, and this one is about average for utility. The drawers are adjustable, in that you can space them the way you want, but they do not pull out. My experience with pull-out shelves is they look good but you can't fill them very well.It took much longer than 1 hour to build, and you will need someone to help you flip the unit as you build it. It is large and heavy, as it is made from MDF.I suggest you calk the seams as you build it with insulating silicon, to improve the energy efficiency. I also calked around the cooling unit, and added weather stripping around the inside of the door frames, for better insulation.The door hangs pretty sturdily, in my build, but you *must* adjust it properly so that the simple magnetic strips (ala a refridgerator) don't bind in the jam, yet still make a full seal.I live in Florida and my cellar worked perfectly for 8 months, keeping my cellar of mostly California wines at my desired temperature of 59 degrees. (The thermostat can be calibrated to match an electronic thermostat, btw.) It just recently froze up with ice, and is not keeping my cellar cool enough, [...].If I had $4K, I'd buy a nice quiet, well insulated cellar, but for my budget this has been a nice upgrade from my little 50-bottle cooler.


By RedLoverJim

from Fort Worth, TX

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

(2 of 2 customers found this review helpful)

Good for the money

 
3.0

Pros

  • Attractive Design
  • Good value
  • Precise Temperature

Cons

  • Loud
  • Limited shelf adjustment

Best Uses

  • Family Room
  • Bar

This unit was fairly easy to assemble. The only thing that didn't work was the sealant that came with it, which was messy, hard to apply and in short supply. [$] at a hardware store bought a caulk gun and slicone sealant that worked MUCH better, cleaner and faster. This unit is a little noisy to put in a dining room or other room where noise may be an issue. A family room or bar would work better, where the rougher edges and corners might not be as big of a deal.


By Now an expert

from Northern New Jersey

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

(1 of 1 customer found this review helpful)

Very difficult to assemble

 
1.0

Pros

  • Attractive Design

Cons

  • Innacurate Temperature

Best Uses

  • Commercial Use
  • Bar
  • Basement
  • Restaurant
  • Kitchen

Poor assembly instructions - You MUST be very good with assembly and tools or get someone else to assemble it. I'm pretty expert and it took me a day.[...].Poor calibration of the thermostat - Gave 55 when set to 59. Very stable control after that. I wish they told me how to adjust the calibration.Shelves on one side aligned at a slight angle.Attractive and solid when finished. I would recommend the finished product, but be aware of the difficult assembly.


By Tim

from Chicago

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

Build your own 500 bottle cabinet

 
4.0

Pros

  • Furniture like in appear
  • Precise Temperature
  • Attractive Design

Cons

Best Uses

  • Great roomfamily room

went together very well with minor challenges. very high quality. some of the new larger format bottles dont fit end to end but still able to make them work. great product.


By Jason

from Maryland

About Me Aspiring Enthusiast

Verified

(1 of 1 customer found this review helpful)

Satisfied

 
4.0

Pros

  • Adjustable Shelving
  • Attractive Design
  • Precise Temperature

Cons

  • Loud

Best Uses

  • Basement

Easy to put together. Requires two people. All in all very happy with the product based on the price. Time will tell if it lasts.


Page 1 2 of 2 | Next


Review Search by Review Search powered by SLI Systems and Review Search powered by Power Reviews


Wine Enthusiast FREE Email Alerts Sign up today & receive our FREE Guide: Wine Enthusiast Magazine's The Top Wines and Spirits of 2008
GET IT NOW
Our Guarantee | Customer Care | Warranty Registration | FAQ's | About Us | Privacy Policy | Site Map | New Products | Catalog Quick Order
Business Gifts | Affiliate Program | Wine Enthusiast Magazine | Gift Registry | Wholesale Program | Shipping | Customer Reviews | Opt-Out

Social Media: Winston's Wisdoms Blog | UnReserved Blogs | Twitter | RSS | Facebook

Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Discover, Bill Me Later, PayPal
Ordering by phone? Use code: WEBSU09
wine_web04